Cyd Notter, Founder of The Plan A Diet™, Nutrition Educator/Author

Aren’t Potatoes Fattening?

August 20, 2025 By Cyd Notter

A few years ago, while at the grocery store check-out line, the cashier made the two following comments:

As he scanned and examined a bag of lentils, he actually asked me if this was a food we eat for lent (seriously). I explained what a lentil is……he had obviously never heard of them.
After scanning all of my groceries, he commented “boy, the only thing fattening you have here is that bag of potatoes.” I politely remarked that potatoes aren’t fattening, but when he made another similar comment, I explained that it’s the TOPPINGS that make potatoes fattening, not the potato itself. I don’t think it sank in.

His comment about potatoes led me to shed some light on the poor little potato, often blamed for everything from being a dreaded, fattening carb to having too high of a glycemic index.

Safe for Diabetics?

Both potatoes and sweet potatoes are nutritious, delicious tubers which can be made into awesome main entrees or side dishes. And both fit into a healthy diet no matter if your goal is weight loss, health improvement, or both.

And yes, potatoes are SAFE for diabetics; in fact, a whole-food, plant-based diet including starches is able to REVERSE Type 2 Diabetes. Why ‘manage’ diabetes when we can mostly likely get rid of it? Even the American Diabetes Association agrees that a plant based diet is more effective at lowering A1C than the ADA guidelines.

Complex carbs such as potatoes are the body’s main source of energy, and our brains also depend on such carbs (remember, there’s a BIG difference between complex carbs such as whole potatoes verses refined carbs such as French fries and potato chips).

When Do Potatoes Become Fattening?

It’s a common misconception that starchy foods such as potatoes are fattening. Potatoes are a nutritious, calorie-dilute, complex carbohydrate – and only 1% of its calories come from fat.

UNTIL … we fry that potato in grease to make French fries (46% fat), or convert that potato into potato chips (56% fat). Or until we smother that potato with butter, sour cream, cheese sauce, and bacon bits – which adds a huge dose of fat (and cholesterol).

As you can see, the potato at 1% fat isn’t adding to our weight struggles. It’s when we convert that complex carb potato into a REFINED junk food carb that our troubles begin.

Are Starches Converted to Fat?

People often believe that the sugars in starches are readily converted to fat, which is then stored in our bellies, hips and butts. But while it’s true that complex carbs break down into simple sugars, these sugars are absorbed into the blood stream and transported to trillions of cells throughout the body for energy.

Some reasons why potatoes aren’t fattening (from Dr. McDougall’s newsletter):

1) Potatoes Aren’t Calorie Dense. Potatoes are at the bottom of the list of calorie dense foods, at one calorie per gram. By comparison, sugar, cheese, and beef are about 4 calories per gram and vegetable oils are 9 calories per gram.
2) The Fat You Eat Is the Fat You Wear. Potatoes are 1% fat – so there are virtually no fat calories to wear (by comparison, cheese can be 70% fat and butter is 100% fat).
3) Carbohydrate Satisfies the Hunger Drive. Potatoes are at the top of the carbohydrate list with about 90% of the calories from appetite-satisfying carbohydrates. (On the other hand, beef, fish, chicken, butter, and olive oil are a few examples of commonly consumed foods with no carbohydrates).

All bets are off if you top your potatoes with butter, margarine, sour cream, cheese, bacon bits or other added fats. It’s those high-fat toppings which contribute to the increase in heart disease, diabetes, arthritis, dementia and other chronic disease – not the potato itself.

Fortunately, there are many healthy toppings we can choose, such as salsa, soups, chilies, dressings, low-fat guacamole, or this delicious Golden Gravy.

Yummy Potato Recipes

There are hundreds of healthy potato recipes out there……here are just a few of our favorites:

Fat-Free Cheese Sauce – great for Cheesy/Broccoli Baked Potatoes!

Sweet Potato Broccoli Cheese Soup

Sweet Potato and White Bean Curry Soup

Instant Pot Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Fit Fries

Potato Salad

Cocoa Black Bean Chili with Roasted Potatoes

Yukon Golds topped with Mushroom Gravy

Bottom Line

Potatoes are a nutritious, satisfying comfort food which contain vitamins, minerals, fiber, anti-oxidants and phytochemicals (with no cholesterol or fat) – and we can enjoy them freely when they are prepared correctly without the added junk.

Pass the gravy!

**************

To learn more about calorie density, watch this free webinar “3 Food Mistakes Which Lead to Painful Joints, Extra Pounds, and Health Problems the Doctors Aren’t Solving.”

Can you overeat on a plant-based diet?

February 19, 2025 By Cyd Notter

Weight gain typically boils down to two reasons…

Reason #1: Too much food (even on a plant-based diet)

The lifestyle medicine docs we follow advise that we do NOT to count calories or points, or weigh/measure our foods; the main reason is because plant-based eating isn’t a typical short-term “diet” of restriction, but rather a lifestyle to be practiced and enjoyed for life.

The advice is to eat when you’re hungry, but stop when you’re comfortably full. And therein lies the key. Stop before you’re stuffed. STOP when you are full.

However, the principle of ‘calories in, calories out’ still applies to the whole food, plant-based lifestyle – because overeating ANY type of food will sabotage our efforts to lose or maintain a healthy weight. Don’t be obsessed with calorie counting…but do tune in to recognize your true hunger signals; eat when you are hungry, and STOP when you’re comfortably full.

Check out this article: Is it hunger, or cravings?

Keeping a food journal of everything you consume (both food and beverages) for several days is another good way to become aware of how much you’re actually eating/ grazing/ snacking.

Meal planning is also important. We tend to overeat when we’re ravenous; and when there’s nothing prepared in the fridge or pantry, we tend to grab anything and everything just to get something in our bellies. Here are some menu planning tips and a 21-day meal plan which may be of help.

NOTE: If food addiction or emotional eating are triggering you to overeat, getting to the root cause of those behaviors will be instrumental. Feel free to contact me for more resources.

Reason #2: The wrong foods (even on a plant-based diet)

This is a trap I see many plant-based eaters fall into. If weight loss and/or health improvement are your major goals, avoiding or limiting high fat plant foods such as avocado, nuts, nut butters, seeds and tahini, olives, and coconut is important. If you do choose to consume them, use them very sparingly, as condiments only. (Note: If you have heart disease, refer to Dr. Esselstyn’s book for more advice about avoiding fats.) And of course – no oils!

Oils are 100% pure fat and should be eliminated in all cases. It’s easy to pack on a few pounds every month by just consuming oils which add no bulk to your food – only calories and fat (not to mention the health problems they contribute to.) Read your labels and avoid products which contain oils and/or hydrogenated oils.

Focus on foods that are low in calorie density (and thereby lower in fat, as well).

Avoid refined grains (do you know how to spot them? This course will help!) Refined grains are devoid of any fiber and can spike our blood sugar.

Make water your first beverage of choice. Avoid sugary drinks, sodas, lattes, and power drinks; in other words, don’t drink your calories.

Bottom Line: Focus on low-fat, high fiber, calorie dilute whole plant foods; use higher fat plant foods as condiments. Drink lots of water. Be mindful of when you’re eating: eat when you’re actually hungry, and stop when your comfortably full.

********************************************

Learn MORE tips in this free webinar: 3 Food Mistakes that Lead to Painful Joints, Extra Pounds, and Health Problems the Doctors Aren’t Solving.

Get a signed copy of my book: The “Plan A” Diet: Combining Whole Food, Plant Based Nutrition with the Timeless Wisdom of Scripture.

EASY Plant-Based Recipes for Busy Holiday Months

December 1, 2024 By Cyd Notter

We’re officially in the toughest season for those trying to stay on-track with their diets. The period between Thanksgiving to New Year’s Day is typically when we give ourselves unspoken permission to over-indulge…we might tell ourselves, “it’s the holidays, after all!”

Plus, it’s hard to stay diligent when you’re surrounded by candies, baked goods, and high-calorie beverages.

So what can you do? Two things come to mind:

You can make your “holiday game plan” now. By planning out a few targeted goals, you can still enjoy the holidays without compromising your health. Read more about it here.
Don’t add to your stress by planning elaborate meals during the week. Eat simply by making these quick, easy meals which are featured in The 21-Day Meal Plan. Another way to save time in the kitchen is by batch cooking once or twice a week. Watch this video for my batch cooking suggestions.

Remember, surviving the holidays is not about deprivation!

It’s about forming a strategy to eat healthy, delicious foods while avoiding the temptation of all those high-calorie, high-fat weight- and health-busters. As an extra bonus, you’ll avoid the guilt AND the bloat when the holidays are over. 🙂

A sensible person sees trouble and hides,
but naive people keep going and pay the penalty. (Proverbs 27:12, EHV)

Great Christmas gift! Order a signed copy of my book 🙂 – I’ll ship it free anywhere in the continental U.S.

Free Webinar: 3 Food Mistakes that Lead to Painful Joints, Extra Pounds, and Health Problems the Doctors Aren’t Solving

Online Courses are Available Here

The “5 Whys” Technique – An Effective Problem Solver When it Comes to Your Health :)

October 7, 2024 By Cyd Notter

(The following is an excerpt from the book, The “Plan A” Diet.)

The 5 Whys Technique

Several years ago, my husband shared with me an interesting technique that automotive manufacturers use to analyze the root cause of problems in their manufacturing processes. The Toyota Motor Corporation originally used this technique—called the 5 Whys—as a problem-solving activity to determine the underlying causes of any glitches in their systems or products.

The nature of a problem, as well as the solution, can become clear by asking the question why five times. The number five is just a guideline. It may take only three questions to reach a conclusion, or it might take six or more; but this questioning method prompts deeper thinking by repeatedly asking why until you get to the bottom of an issue.

A very simplistic example shown on Wikipedia[i] reads as follows:

Problem: The vehicle will not start.

Why? – The battery is dead.
Why? – The alternator is not functioning.
Why? – The alternator belt has broken.
Why? – The alternator belt was well beyond its useful service life and not replaced.
Why? – The vehicle was not maintained according to the recommended service schedule. (Fifth why – the root cause)

The solution, therefore, is to assure the vehicle and its belts are maintained according to the service schedule.

I love the simplicity of The 5 Whys…

…and the moment my husband explained it to me, a light bulb came on in my head: What a great way to get people thinking about the cause-and-effect of food!

Although The 5 Whys can be used as a tool to evaluate all types of problems, I believe it can be especially effective when dealing with health issues. Not only can it help identify the root cause of a medical problem, it can save the hassle, time, and money that might have otherwise been spent pursuing a perceived but ineffective solution.

It’s wise to write your questions and answers on a sheet of paper and continue asking why until you get to the bottom of things. Ask friends or family to join you in this exercise; group think can lead to other ideas and thought patterns. Here’s one simplified example of how it might look:

Problem: Diagnosis of Type 2 Diabetes

1. Why? There’s too much glucose in the blood.
2. Why is there too much glucose? The glucose remains in the bloodstream because it can’t get where it needs to go – the intended muscle cells. (Picture each cell as having a door with a lock on it. Insulin is the key that “unlocks” the cell’s door and allows glucose to enter. Having excess glucose in the bloodstream indicates the insulin isn’t unlocking the cell’s door.)[ii]
3. Why isn’t the insulin unlocking the cell’s doors? The cells have become resistant to insulin.
4. Why are the cells insulin resistant? Excess fat has accumulated inside the cells. The cell’s locks are gummed up and compromised by intramyocellular lipids (fat), which interferes with insulin’s ability to open the doors.
5. Why are the cells compromised with fat? Fat from the bloodstream has built up inside the muscle cells and is blocking the pathway process. (It should be noted here that even slim people can accumulate fat within the muscle cells.)
6. Why is there fat in the bloodstream? Most likely the consumption of a high-fat, Standard American Diet (or the fat produced from one’s own fat stores).

When diet is deemed to be the root cause of the problem…

…the solution becomes clear: choose to change the foods being consumed. Doing so allows the body to stop the on-going damage being done three times a day and begins the healing process needed to reverse the underlying issue.

Unfortunately, most healthcare providers aren’t telling you that.

The medical system is instead geared primarily to treat your symptoms and control your blood biomarkers—which usually occurs at the first why. As a result, the underlying problem remains unresolved and continues to worsen slowly because the prescribed treatment doesn’t deal with the real issue—the food.

Using the 5 Whys technique can be an eye-opening exercise to help you discover the root cause of a health issue. So be like a curious toddler and keep asking why until you get a satisfactory answer.

One caveat with The 5 Whys technique:

The 5 Whys technique is limited to a person’s knowledge base. If the knowledge base doesn’t exist to examine the issue logically or ask the right questions, the root cause may not be fully understood. For this reason, I always encourage clients, friends, and readers to stay engaged in continual learning when it comes to diet and health.

Heed the principle of Proverbs 18:15—be an intelligent person who is always ready to learn.

The more you understand how food affects every system in your body, the better equipped you’ll be to overcome your weight and health issues by recognizing their root cause. So please continue to learn and stay in the loop!

One way to keep learning is with this free class, “3 Food Mistakes Which Lead to Painful Joints, Extra Pounds, and Health Problems the Doctors Aren’t Solving.” Check it out!

The Resource section on this site also lists websites which offer free webinars and instructional videos from credible doctors, daily blogs from renowned researchers, educational DVDs, books, and much more.

**********************************************

[i] Wikipedia, “5 Whys.” Accessed January 13, 2018. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5_Whys

[ii] Dr. Michael Greger, “What Causes Insulin Resistance?” Dated January 6, 2017. Accessed January 13, 2018. http://nutritionfacts.org/video/what-causes-insulin-resistance/

Takeaways from the 2024 NHA Conference

July 1, 2024 By Cyd Notter

The 2024 NHA Conference…

…once again did not disappoint in any way! The speaker presentations, hiking to a waterfall, live music, compliant foods, Dandy-blend frappaccinos, and meeting old and new friends was a wonderful experience indeed.

A Few Takeaways – the Nut-Shell Version

Dr. Greg Fitzgerald, a physician from Australia: His talk focused on ENERGY. You cannot achieve a higher level of health without achieving a higher level of energy; you need energy to heal. Stimulated energy (from coffee, energy drinks, etc.) is not REAL energy; the provide temporary energy and then you’ll crash. Tired people will not lose weight because that takes energy. Exercise is not the answer. Don’t PUSH yourself when you’re tired. You need REST and SLEEP, the right food, balanced activity, and emotional poise (such as not trying to change other people).

Dr. Frank Sabatino: Body fat is now a global pandemic. As body fat increases, every known cancer to man increases as well. You can be normal weight and have a normal BMI – and still be over fat. His new book, Weightless: Compassionate Weight Loss for Life, explains 6 pillars that follow the PAMPER acronym: Plant nutrition, Adrenal recovery, Microbiota support, Pyschological poise, Exercise (and environmental toxins), and Rest/Sleep. I purchased a copy and look forward to reading it.

Dr. Neal Barnard: Talked about his latest book, The Power Foods Diet. He talked about foods that tame our appetite, trap calories, and boost metabolism. He suggests to his clients to spend one week just thinking about what they’ll eat for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and snack, and to write all the options down. He reported that they always have long lists after thinking about it for an entire week. Then they spend the next 3 weeks DOING it.

Dr. Alan Goldhammer: Food addiction was one of his biggest points. He explained why chemicals in Sugar, Oil, and Salt laden foods are so addictive, and how they lead to visceral fat (belly fat). Visceral fat produces inflammation and leads to cardiovascular disease, hypertension, type 2 diabetes, autoimmune disorders, and more.

He said having visceral fat is like having a 2-pound tumor in the belly. 72% of people in industrialized countries are overweight or obese. He also explained that losing weight permanently is even tougher than staying sober when recovering from alcohol or drug addiction, but that it CAN be done. His latest book was also on display, Can Fasting Save Your Life?

Dr. Joel Furhman: There’s an optimal weight for each person. You cannot be overweight AND healthy, because fat cells produce inflammation issues, hormone changes, and glucose/insulin resistance problems. Eating the right foods makes you desire LESS calories, while eating the wrong foods makes you desire more. Eating fewer calories slows the aging process. He described the “caloric rush” – caloric concentration in the blood stream, and showed charts of the calories in our blood after eating high fat meals. One more tip I though was worth noting: If you plan to eat healthy desserts (such as frozen fruit nice cream), desserts should be PART of your meal, not in addition to your meal.

You Can Watch ALL of it

Other doctors who presented included Dr. Caldwell Esselstyn and Laurie Marbas; cooking demos were provided by Cathy Fisher, and Jane and Ann Esselstyn. Plus Chuck Carroll from the Exam Room Podcast shared his incredible transformation story.

You do have the opportunity to watch every one of these presentations (including the music on Saturday night; Dr. Sabatino plays a MEAN harmonica! They were rockin’.)

Visit the NHA’s Website and click on the Conference tab to purchase the conference replays. The 2024 Conference replays should be available shortly.

Also consider becoming an NHA member – it’s only $35/year, and you’ll receive a quarterly, high quality, ad-free magazine in your physical mailbox (not email inbox) which is amazing! Lastly, tickets are now available for the 2025 conference, being held June 27-29, 2025. We plan on attending again would love to see you there!